German animal law · practical guidance
What counts as a defect?
The question is whether the animal meets the agreed and legally required standard at the relevant time. Health, age, training, breeding characteristics and suitability for an agreed purpose may matter. A veterinary finding is evidence to assess, not an automatic legal conclusion. Animals are expressly not things under section 90a BGB, although property rules generally apply correspondingly.
Evidence and timing
Preserve the advert, contract, disclosures, examination report and dated veterinary findings. For a consumer purchase of a living animal from a trader, section 477 BGB provides a six-month evidential presumption, subject to its conditions and exceptions. It is not the period within which every claim must be brought.
A practical example
A horse develops lameness after delivery. The diagnosis, likely onset, contractual standard and any pre-existing findings must be assessed together. Urgent care comes first; where possible, retain diagnostic records and inform the seller before taking steps that may affect available remedies.
Related advice
- Animal sales and purchase disputes
- Veterinary practices and clinics
- Disputes, urgent relief and defence
Legal framework: German Civil Code; Veterinary Fee Regulation; Veterinary professional statute. Reviewed 8 November 2026.
Discuss your matter
Send a short description, the parties involved and any deadline. We check conflicts and agree the scope and fees before starting work. For urgent matters, telephone our office as well.