horak.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW/ PARTNERSHIP mBB /
LAWYERS / PATENT ATTORNEYS

ANIMAL LAW – German Attorneys at law

Animal law, horse law and animal liability in Germany

Tribunal Decisions

Case law: what the decisions mean in practice

Gross veterinary treatment errors

BGH, 10.05.2016 – VI ZR 247/15

A qualifying gross treatment error can reverse the burden of proving causation. This is not automatic liability for every poor outcome. The assessment of the error and the particular injury remain central.

Read the BGH decision (German)

Dogs and cats in tenancy agreements

BGH, 20.03.2013 – VIII ZR 168/12

A blanket dog-and-cat prohibition in standard tenancy terms can be invalid. Whether keeping a particular animal is permitted still depends on the circumstances. The judgment does not establish an unrestricted right to keep animals.

Read the BGH decision (German)

These judgments date from 2013 and 2016. They are discussed for their practical relevance, not presented as new 2026 decisions.

Judgments & Tribunal Decisions sorted by topic – at least in guiding principles – are presented and listed on the following pages. In addition to the guiding principles, summaries of the facts and comments on the judgements can also be found. Comments reflect our opinion and cannot claim to be exhaustive.
Please always remember that every tribunal decision – even a supreme court one – is based on a particular individual case. Generalisations are therefore usually neither possible nor meaningful. Rather, an examination of the individual facts often appears to be necessary.
So far, we have filed the following decisions (judgments and resolutions):

2022 reform review: the EU veterinary medicines framework

A retrospective on the EU veterinary medicines framework introduced in 2022 and its significance for product businesses and veterinary practices.

0 comments

2016 case review: gross veterinary treatment errors

A review of the 2016 veterinary negligence case and the evidential questions raised by gross treatment errors.

0 comments

EU dog and cat welfare: planning for the new framework

What breeders, sellers and shelters should examine when planning for the new EU dog and cat welfare framework, including the distinction between adoption and application dates.

0 comments

Animal transport in 2026: current duties and proposed reform

A practical distinction between existing animal transport duties and proposed reform, with priorities for transport businesses.

0 comments

Veterinary product information: preparing for January 2027

Product-information planning for veterinary medicine authorisation holders ahead of the January 2027 transition deadline.

0 comments

Medicated feed in 2026: homogeneity and cross-contamination

How the Commission’s 2026 guidance relates to homogeneity and cross-contamination controls in medicated feed production.

0 comments

Urgent animal-law proceedings in 2026: deadlines and evidence

In an urgent matter, first identify the precise result sought. Recovering an animal, challenging a closure order and preserving a clinical finding require different steps. A general assertion of urgency is insufficient: explain deadlines, threatened consequences and available evi

Veterinary medicines in 2026: distribution and product responsibility

Veterinary medicines businesses should distinguish regulatory roles from contractual tasks. Authorisation holders, manufacturers, wholesalers and other partners do not automatically have identical duties. A clear allocation helps direct records, changes and reports to the right p

Welfare inspections in 2026: findings, remedies and legal protection

After a welfare inspection, prompt orientation and reliable documentation matter. Which findings relate to which animals, what action is required and by when? A structured response helps remedy valid concerns and correct inaccurate assumptions with evidence.

Animal insurance in 2026: coverage before and after a loss

Insurance should match the animal’s actual use. Private keeping, commercial activity, care of others’ animals and sporting use can raise different questions. Clarify the position before changing activities where possible, not only after the first loss.

Legal assessment and practical approach

Read judicial decisions in light of the facts, legal issue and reasoning. A headnote cannot be applied to every case independently of those conditions. The following hypothetical examples explain preparation for litigation; they are not additional reports of judgments.

Four practical examples

These are hypothetical scenarios illustrating issues to assess. They do not describe actual client matters or promise a particular outcome.

Practical example 1

An emergency is referred to a clinic late. Reconstruct timing, available treatment and warning signs. An expert can assess whether delay could have affected the outcome.

Practical example 2

An illness appears in month five after handover. Separate the burden of proof from diagnosis and legal defect assessment. The live-animal rule does not eliminate the need to identify a departure from contractual requirements.

Practical example 3

A landlord relies on a blanket dog ban in standard terms. Review enforceability and the particular interests involved. Neither an unrestricted right to keep animals nor the validity of every prohibition follows automatically.

Practical example 4

A manager receives notice of an alleged regulatory offence. Examine the allegation, personal responsibility and available records first. A premature explanation can be difficult to correct, while response deadlines still need attention.

Prepare the relevant evidence

Provide complete documents and a concise chronology. Distinguish your observations from statements by others and unresolved questions. Include attachments, evidence of service and deadlines with official notices and correspondence. Preserve original files, images and message histories unchanged; an organised working copy assists review.

Tell us about your matter and deadlines

Scroll to top